Buchner was a stud recruit. You said we should get 1 stud recruit every 2 years. If you are only going to judge by hindsight your standards are unrealistic.
And as for 2023, the issue with 2022 was he was late in evaluating and offering. You can't say that about 2023. So, no, the results aren't yet better, but the process is.
So why the knee jerk reaction based on 1 recruiting class?