Posted August 28, 2024Aug 28 VS I wanted to talk to @NDLincPark and others who didn't get a chance to vote in the All time best player project. Pick your player, defend your choice! Have fun!
August 28, 2024Aug 28 Tuck was a freak. IMO the case could be made that had he stayed his senior year, 2005, we MAY have made the NC game and ended as Champs possibly. I don't know if he was seriously considering going pro during the season, but I'm pretty sure he was vocal about his displeasure of TW being fired and themes that were stirred up by the media etc... He was a bit gimped up his Jr year too, and having a healthy senior season would have vaulted him to a 1st round pick IMO. I guess things worked out for him in the end 😉. Tuck drew lots of double teams, moreso than I remember Foskey getting. Both were great players but I choose Tuck.
August 29, 2024Aug 29 No question Jesse. I don’t even think this is a question. It was Tuck holds records at ND and was just dominant at times. I never felt that way with Foskey. Foskey disappeared in games.
August 29, 2024Aug 29 Author I had a mission in mind for this post. Didn't quite work out. So we're declaring Justin Tuck the winner for this one @Mike is there a cool way to do this I've been workshopping some cool new thread ideas This idea was inspired by the MTV show of my Youth Celebrity Deathmatch My player choices we not shocking enough I got it Lets put the annoying head coaches against each other. Thoughts?
August 30, 2024Aug 30 Author 3 minutes ago, NYGoldenDomer said: Lol I loved that show. me too brother
August 30, 2024Aug 30 Love Foskey, Tuck is legend. I know this thread says at ND but I can’t separate out Tucks prolific NFL career so it is a bad comparison. Maybe in 10 years I will have a different opinion. But then maybe in ten years UNICEF gets into the impound business and I will be able to get my HEMI back.
August 30, 2024Aug 30 I actually didn’t start following Notre Dame closely until the 2005 season, so I never saw Tuck play. I’ve seen highlights, but saw plenty of Foskey play. With that being said, Foskey is now the all time Sack Leader, so I’m going to give Foskey ‘Best Pash Rusher at Notre Dame’ all time!
VS
I wanted to talk to @NDLincPark and others who didn't get a chance to vote in the All time best player project.
Pick your player, defend your choice!
Have fun!