Yes he really does suck! Jurkovec now!

Brutal.........

The guy makes throwing the football look like rocket science.

does Wimbush become to automatic start next year, or could there be a competition with Book? I've liked Wimbush's ability to scramble and run. that is a good quality to have, but too often his throwing hurts more.

Kid has no real fight...look at the way he carries himself when down...

Kid has no real fight...look at the way he carries himself when down...

 

This ^^^^^^^^ x10

No way he is an automatic starter. Move him to receiver or something but he is not related to a CFB QB the past month. His throws are so bad it is hard to get your head around it.

I see Carlyle Holiday in his future

He cant read a defense. Id like to see him used as a change up qb next year for a drive or two. I hope Book develops or the freshman is as good as advertised.

He looks like a good running back who can throw some. He would be awesome in Navy or Georgia Tech's offense.

Yes he does.

Brutal.........

 

Good kid but that doesn’t mean you get to be starting qb at Nd.

He looks like a good running back who can throw some. He would be awesome in Navy or Georgia Tech's offense.

 

He can’t read the defensive end well. He never understands when to pull or hand it off.

I think its worth noting that every qb under Kelly has regressed and actually gotten worse as their career went on. Wimbush was better at the beginning of the year.

He cant read a defense. Id like to see him used as a change up qb next year for a drive or two. I hope Book develops or the freshman is as good as advertised.

 

I’d like to see him transfer to a lower division school and be average.

Yes...........

So do all of our QBs since Clausen suck? What terrible luck is that? Oh wait it isn’t luck, it is one guy who has consistently misused abused confused and destroyed talented QB prospects.

 

You would think the fact that we have a QB sucks thread every year would you up someone off.

He can’t read the defensive end well. He never understands when to pull or hand it off.

 

They have coaches at those other locations who could probably fix that.

 

"...misused abused confused and destroyed talented QB prospects." That's gold right there Jerry. Gold!

I’d like to see him transfer to a lower division school and be average.

 

Gee Wiz you are a sad man

They have coaches at those other locations who could probably fix that.

 

"...misused abused confused and destroyed talented QB prospects." That's gold right there Jerry. Gold!

 

I was going for an Al Sharpton thing but I ran out of rhymes.

Yes he's bad. After 1 season he showed no growth. His pump fake actually draws the centerfield safety over. His slowly lobbed ball, slightly underthrown, is intercepted by the opponent he tipped off with his own pump fake. Unreal. After overthrowing his TE on a busted coverage TD on the previous play. Can't wait for ND to have a great QB again...and Kizer wasn't that; a turnover machine. He could thread it one play and then quickly throw an interception into double coverage when we were in total control game wise. Brady Quinn was literally the last great QB in my eyes. Not Golson's one awesome year, or Clausen who had amazing talent but fell short.

 

Off topic - I was so excited with CJ Sanders early on, and after he fumbled against Clemson and just killed our comeback (a game we still almost won if Kelly didn't randomly go for a two point conversion when nobody knew whether we'd need that or not at the end of the game. Corey Robinson let it go right through his hands and Chris Brown fumbles deep near the end zone when we're dominating as well), he was never given the same responsibility. Yet again, Sanders fumbles during a big game when we just need players to make plays. It's the same players who just kill this team during big games. Wimbush and Sanders.